Puzzles
Largest triangle
What is the largest area triangle which has one side of length 4cm and one of length 5cm?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
As our shape is a triangle, the 4cm and 5cm sides must be adjacent. Call the angle between them be \(\theta\).
The area of the triangle is \(\frac{1}{2}\times 4\times 5 \times \sin{\theta}\) or \(10\sin{\theta}\). This has a maximum value when \(\theta=90^\circ\), so the largest triangle has and area of 10cm2 and looks like:
Extension
What is the largest area triangle with a perimeter of 12cm?
Circles
Which is largest, the red or the blue area?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
Let \(4x\) be the side length of the square. This means that the radius of the red circle is \(2x\) and the radius of a blue circle is \(x\). Therefore the area of the red circle is \(4\pi x^2\).
The area of one of the blue squares is \(\pi x^2\) so the blue area is \(4\pi x^2\). Therefore the two areas are the same.
Extension
Is the red or blue area larger?
Semi circle in a triangle
This right-angled triangle above has sides of lengths 12cm, 5cm and 13cm. The diameter of the semicircle lies on the 12cm side and the 13cm side is a tangent to the circle. What is the radius of the semi circle?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
Label the triangle as follows:
EC and BC are both tangents to the circle so FEA is a right angle and the lengths EC and BC are equal, so the length of EC is 5. Let r be the radius of the circle.
Using Pythagoras' Theorem in triangle FEA:
$$8^2+r^2=(12-r)^2$$
$$64+r^2=144-24r+r^2$$
$$24r=80$$
$$r=\frac{80}{24}=\frac{10}{3}$$
Extension
What is the radius of the circle whose diameter lies on the 5cm side and to which the 12cm and 13cm sides are tangents?
What is the radius of the circle whose diameter lies on the 13cm side and to which the 12cm and 5cm sides are tangents?
Additional observation
For each pair of semi circles, draw a straight line between the two points where the semi circles intersect. These lines all meet at a point.
Light work
"I don't know if you are fond of puzzles, or not. If you are, try this. ... A gentleman (a nobleman let us say, to make it more interesting) had a sitting-room with only one window in it—a square window, 3 feet high and 3 feet wide. Now he had weak eyes, and the window gave too much light, so (don't you like 'so' in a story?) he sent for the builder, and told him to alter it, so as only to give half the light. Only, he was to keep it square—he was to keep it 3 feet high—and he was to keep it 3 feet wide. How did he do it? Remember, he wasn't allowed to use curtains, or shutters, or coloured glass, or anything of that sort."
Equal areas
An equilateral triangle and a square have the same area. What is the ratio of the perimeter of the triangle to the perimeter of the square?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
Let \(A\) be the area of the square (and the triangle).
The length of a side of the square is \(\sqrt{A}\), so the perimeter of the square is \(4\sqrt{A}\).
Let \(l\) be the length of a side the triangle. Then \(\frac{1}{2}l^2\sin{60}=A\), so \(l^2=\frac{4A}{\sqrt{3}}\). Therefore \(l=\frac{2\sqrt{A}}{3^\frac{1}{4}}\) and the perimeter of the triangle is \(\frac{6\sqrt{A}}{3^\frac{1}{4}}\).
Hence the ratio of the perimeters is \(\frac{6\sqrt{A}}{3^\frac{1}{4}} : 4\sqrt{A}\) which simplifies to 33/4:2
Extension
If an \(n\) sided regular polygon has the area \(A\), what is the length of one of its sides?
Rebounds
In a 4x3 rectangle, a ball is fired from the top left corner at 45°.
It bounces around a rectangle until it hits a corner. Which corner does it end in?
Which corner will it end in for rectangles of other sizes?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
If mirrors were placed along the walls of the rectangle, the ball would appear to travel in a straight line across a grid of rectangles:
Viewed this way, the ball will still stop once it reaches a corner:
For an \(n\) by \(m\) (in above example: \(n=4\), \(m=3\)) rectangle, this will occur once the ball has travelled through \(\mathrm{lcm}(n,m)\) squares.
$$\mathrm{Let\ }a=\frac{\mathrm{lcm}(n,m)}{n}$$
$$\mathrm{Let\ }b=\frac{\mathrm{lcm}(n,m)}{m}$$
On its way to the corner, the ball will bounce \(b-1\) times off the top and bottom and \(a-1\) times off the sides. It can be seen that if \(a-1\) is even, then the ball will end in one of the corners on the right hand side. The complete results can be seen in the following
Carroll diagram:
| \(a-1\) odd | \(a-1\) even |
\(b-1\) odd | Top left | Top right |
\(b-1\) even | Bottom left | Bottom right |
It can be shown that the ball will never finish in the top left (where it started) as this would require it to travel through the bottom right first. Therefore the following holds:
| \(a\) even | \(a\) odd |
\(b\) even | | Top right |
\(b\) odd | Bottom left | Bottom right |
Extension
For which sizes of rectangle will the path of the ball make the same pattern?
Ellipses
A piece of string 10cm long is tied to two pins 6cm apart.
The string is used to draw an ellipse. The pins are then moved 2cm further apart and a second ellipse is drawn. Which ellipse has the larger area?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
The area of an ellipse is \(\pi ab\) where \(a\) and \(b\) are the distances from the centre of the ellipse to the closest and furthest points on the ellipse.
In the first ellipse, \(a=5\mathrm{cm}\) and \(b=4\mathrm{cm}\), so the area is \(20\pi\mathrm{cm}^2\). In the second ellipse, \(a=5\mathrm{cm}\) and \(b=3\mathrm{cm}\), so the area is \(15\pi\mathrm{cm}^2\). Hence, the first ellipse has the larger area.
Extension
How far apart should the pins be placed to give the ellipse with the largest area?
Folding tube maps
Back in 2012, I posted instructions for
folding a tetrahedron from tube maps. When tube maps are used, the sides of the tetrahedron are not quite equal. What ratio would the rectangular maps need to be in to give a regular tetrahedron?
Show answer & extension
Hide answer & extension
Once the map is folded, it will look like this:
For the final tetrahedron to be regular, the red lengths must be equal. Let each red length be 2 (this will get rid of halves in the upcoming calculations). By drawing a vertical line in we can work out the width and height of the rectangle:
The width of the rectangle is 3 (one and a half red lengths). Using Pythagoras' Theorem in the blue triangle, we find that the height of the rectangle is \(\sqrt{3}\). Therefore, the ratio of the rectangle is \(\sqrt{3}:3\) or \(1:\sqrt{3}\).
Extension
If the ratio of the rectangle is \(1:a\), what is the ratio of the lengths of the sides of the tetrahedron?